Katie Moffatt
09.03.2025
Shocking service today. Food was cold, no mash potatoes and meat portions was ridiculously small.
Dinky
07.03.2025
Doesn't get a whole lot better than this for dining. Thank you to all of the staff at T.C. Rotherham xxxxx
Amy Daly
06.03.2025
Marie was the lady who served us and was really friendly and helpful!
laurakeen94
06.03.2025
Lovely breakfast! Fresh and hot!
Faith Shaw
06.03.2025
Slight issue but the manager sorted straight away. Lovely breakfast warm and plentiful.
geoff tonks
08.05.2023
as usual the food was great with it being sunday there is a vast price increase for the carvery why
Epps Again
04.03.2025
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Truly Unforgettable Experience
Walking into Toby Carvery, we expected a warm, homely roast dinner. What we got instead was a fever dream with Yorkshire puddings.
Our evening was graced by Madame Zelda, a waitress who doubled as a psychic and part-time phone enthusiast. She took a “come and go as she pleases” approach to service, frequently disappearing to check her messages in the kitchen (possibly performing tarot readings for the roast beef). At one point, she shouted our order across the restaurant, because nothing says fine dining like a public broadcast of your meal choices.
When the bill finally arrived (after what felt like an entire astrological cycle), we suspected it was incorrect but were too scared to ask.
Over at the carving station, we encountered Mortdecai the Meat Miser, a man who looked as though he had seen things no human should. He did not speak. He did not smile. He merely mechanically sawed at the gammon, his hollow eyes betraying a deep and infinite sadness.
And the food? Well. The meat was fine. The peas had been exorcised of all moisture and crumbled into dust. The roast potatoes were an abomination, somehow both overcooked and undercooked, wrapped in an alien-like skin. The macaroni cheese was simply macaroni with a vague memory of cheese. The roast parsnips? Lethal. If dropped from a height, they could kill a man.
Adding to the ambience was a clientele best described as “varied”, and a mystery woman in loungewear, who may or may not have worked there. She had no uniform, no identification, and an air of casual authority. Was she a rogue diner who took matters into her own hands? We may never know.
And yet—despite the questionable food, unsettling service, and general air of despair—we are giving this visit a solid five stars. Not for the food (obviously), not for the service (good lord, no), and not for the atmosphere (which was actively distressing). But for the memories, the unintentional comedy, and the sheer absurdity of it all.
Would we return? Absolutely not. Would we talk about this night for years to come? Without a doubt.
Lee
20.10.2024
I'm a regular here, mainly breakfast, never disappointed, wide choice of food, relaxing atmosphere. Thanks Sam & Marie. Staff are really friendly.
Saimanta Cernikyte
27.02.2025
Michelle and Marie went way beyond our expectations and satisfied with the 5* service! They deserve to be the best customer service advisors! 💪🏽
No beef left for our carvery at 14:30. Came in and there were no Beef ready, all meats available but not beef. Said will be in 20min, Waited 20min and still not done and not ready at all. It was ready in 40min. Was very sad about that, but lovely staff members Michelle and Marie M&M how they call it, undersood our experience and treated with drinks. They went beyond our expectations. This was much better experience!
Kenny Gilberthorpe
25.02.2025
Excellent food lovely staff Marie & Matt,
Sarah Burgan
24.02.2025
Arrived early and we were seated straightaway. Waitress was very polite and helpful
Lynn Shaw
23.02.2025
Went to Toby carvery Rotherham today 23/02/25,food was lovely,we go regularly and always happy,all staff pleasant look like they enjoy their work,our waitress was Grace,lovely young lady,very polite,not seen her before,maybe new,nothing too much for her, will visit again soon.
francesca winter
20.02.2025
Lovely food, staff always working attentive and friendly especially Michelle always makes you feel welcome.
Dot Cawthorn
18.02.2025
Fantastic
Andy Harrison
17.02.2025
Friendly staff. Just had a drink. No problems.
Arnie Eyre
14.02.2025
It's OK just average carvery nothing much to say.
Meat was a bit tough.
Natalie Louise
13.02.2025
Great breakfast, plenty of choice
Leanne Bott
12.02.2025
Delicious breakfast all you can eat in a nice environment. Staff very friendly special shout out to our servers. Will defo be coming back
Julie Thurston
11.02.2025
We were served by Marie and Kevina , very good friendly service , we will come again .
Susan Adey
11.02.2025
Came for breakfast. Very nice. Friendly staff. Marie and Kerina excellent
Jessie Chapman
11.02.2025
Great staff. Marie and kerine was really helpful and kept checking up on us
Tyler Walker
11.02.2025
Marie was really nice and friendly.
Libby Williams
11.02.2025
We came this morning for our breakfast and the staff Marie was very welcoming took us to our table which was very clean.
Marie came over and asked us if everything was okay and is there anything else she could help us with.
Kevina came over to our table and cleared our plates away and asked us if everything was okay.
Both members of staff was lovely and polite to us
W both enjoyed our breakfast.
Pauline Omara
26.11.2018
I was greeted by marie who welcomed us in she took us to our table and told us all how it worked kevina ask how our meal was and made sure we was happy Marie came back and helped clear the table asking again if everything was ok I felt the staff worked hard and cared about the guest I would recommend this toby as all staff members are very welcoming and courteous
